Rethinking "Gnosticism": An Argument for Dismantling a Dubious Category

Most an individual drawn to such subject matters as production mythology, Jungian idea, or the assumption of "secret teachings" in historical Judaism and Christianity has came across "gnosticism" compelling. but the time period "gnosticism," which regularly connotes a unmarried rebellious circulation opposed to the present religions of past due antiquity, provides the misunderstanding of a monolithic non secular phenomenon. the following Michael Williams demanding situations the validity of the commonly invoked classification of historical "gnosticism" and the methods it's been defined. featuring such well-known writings and pursuits because the Apocryphon of John and Valentinian Christianity, Williams uncovers the similarities and modifications between a few significant traditions largely categorised as gnostic. He presents an eloquent, systematic argument for a extra actual technique to speak about those interpretive approaches.

The smooth build "gnosticism" isn't really justified through any old self-definition, and lots of of the main generally mentioned non secular positive factors that supposedly outline gnosticism phenomenologically grow to be questionable. Exploring the pattern units of "gnostic" teachings, Williams refutes generalizations touching on asceticism and libertinism, attitudes towards the physique and the created international, and alleged positive aspects of protest, parasitism, and elitism. He sketches a clean version for figuring out historical concepts on extra "mainstream" Judaism and Christianity, a version that's expert by way of glossy learn on dynamics in new spiritual pursuits and is free of the fake stereotypes from which the class "gnosticism" has been constructed.

Show description

Quick preview of Rethinking "Gnosticism": An Argument for Dismantling a Dubious Category PDF

Similar Christianity books

The Great Divorce

C. S. Lewis’ the nice Divorce is a vintage Christian allegorical story a few bus experience from hell to heaven. a unprecedented meditation upon strong and evil, grace and judgment, Lewis’s progressive proposal within the the good Divorce is that the gates of Hell are locked from the interior. utilizing his awesome descriptive powers, Lewis’ the good Divorce will switch the best way we expect approximately strong and evil.


Within the vintage Miracles, C. S. Lewis, an important Christian author of the 20 th century, argues Christian mustn't ever in simple terms settle for yet have a good time in miracles as a sworn statement of the original own involvement of God in his creation. 

Sin No More (The Reverend Curtis Black Series)

A guy who as soon as thrived on wickedness and counted on forgiveness, Curtis Black has replaced his methods. again within the center of his congregation and his kinfolk, he'll not stray from the overwhelmed course. Or so he is promised his long-suffering spouse, Charlotte. however the sins of the prior have unusual methods of coming to mild.

The Apocryphal Gospels: Texts and Translations

Bart Ehrman--the long island occasions bestselling writer of Misquoting Jesus and a famous authority at the early Christian Church--and Zlatko Plese right here supply a groundbreaking, multi-lingual version of the Apocryphal Gospels, one who breathes new existence into the non-canonical texts that have been as soon as approximately misplaced to historical past.

Extra info for Rethinking "Gnosticism": An Argument for Dismantling a Dubious Category

Show sample text content

If Irenaeus does basically restrict the designation “gnostics” to a specific sect, as Rousseau and Doutreleau contend, then his testimony a minimum of bargains no aid for the fashionable inclusion of different teams corresponding to the Valentinians lower than the rubric “gnosticism” at the foundation of self-designation. nevertheless, if Brox is right, Irenaeus’s personal utilization of the time period gnostikos easily as a basic synonym for “heretic” will be even much less cause to set up a unique class at the foundation of the meant use of this time period as a self-designation.

3:22 also are situations the place God has to be chatting with “certain others as if they have been fellow staff. ” by way of those, Philo potential God’s numberless “powers” who help him, besides angels. And Philo stresses that God needs to be the reason for good stuff basically, and never of undesirable. therefore the plural in “Come, allow us to move down and confuse their language” needs to point out that God left punishment as much as others. eighty one the tale of Sodom and Gomorrah, with its portrait of indignant punishment through a downpour of sulfur and fire, concerned comparable difficulties.

Intoned because it so frequently is as one of many supposedly average or usual features of “gnosticism,” it truly finds little or no and, as we've seen, conceals greatly that will rather be understood approximately perceptions of physique and soul one of the women and men less than research right here. That this cliché has been one of many favourite development blocks within the sleek building of the class “gnosticism” remains to be one more reason to query the steadiness of the class itself. C H A P T E R S E V E N Asceticism .

Testim. fact 30,2–18) the writer finds the legislation abominable since it instructions what he considers to be the inherently defiling act of sex. there's a comparability of existence within the physique to imprisonment, simply as Irenaeus had defined relating to the Carpocratians. Testim. fact does suggest breaking yes instructions within the legislation, however the aim of resistance is the command to marry and procreate. The readers are to withstand the fervour of sexual activity through ignoring the Law’s command to multiply.

Asserting seventy five) I taught them concerning the passage in which the decide on and the solitary will move. (Dial. Sav. 120,24–26) you're the notion and the entire freedom from care of the solitary; back, pay attention us, simply as you will have heard your opt for. (Dial. Sav. 121,16–20) In Gos. Thom. we find additionally the Coptic expression oua ouôt, “single one,” one other time period used as a designation for the go with. there was confrontation concerning the semantic worth of and courting among those phrases in 146 C H A P T E R S E V E N Gos.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.36 of 5 – based on 16 votes