Challenging Liberalism: Feminism as Political Critique

By Lisa H. Schwartzman

Questions concerning the relevance and cost of assorted liberal recommendations are on the middle of significant debates between feminist philosophers and social theorists. even if many feminists invoke options akin to rights, equality, autonomy, and freedom in arguments for liberation, a few try and steer clear of them, noting that they could additionally toughen and perpetuate oppressive social buildings.

In Challenging Liberalism Schwartzman explores the explanations why strategies similar to rights and equality can occasionally strengthen oppression. She argues that sure sorts of abstraction and individualism are crucial to liberal method and that those provide upward push to a few difficulties. Drawing at the paintings of feminist ethical, political, and felony theorists, she constructs an strategy that employs those ideas, whereas viewing them from inside a critique of social kinfolk of power.

Show description

Quick preview of Challenging Liberalism: Feminism as Political Critique PDF

Similar Political Theory books

Aristotle: A Very Short Introduction

The impression of Aristotle, the prince of philosophers, at the highbrow heritage of the West is moment to none. during this booklet, Jonathan Barnes examines Aristotle's clinical researches, his discoveries in good judgment and his metaphysical theories, his paintings in psychology and in ethics and politics, and his rules approximately artwork and poetry, putting his teachings of their ancient context.

The Myth of Ownership: Taxes and Justice

In a capitalist economic system, taxes are an important device wherein the political procedure places into perform a perception of financial and distributive justice. Taxes arouse powerful passions, fueled not just through conflicts of monetary self-interest, yet through conflicting principles of equity. Taking as a tenet the traditional nature of non-public estate, Murphy and Nagel express how taxes can in simple terms be evaluated as a part of the final method of estate rights that they assist to create.

The Philosophy of Sociality: The Shared Point of View

The Philosophy of Sociality examines the character of sociality in its a variety of varieties, with exact emphasis on collective intentionality. Raimo Tuomela starts off with a contrast among the "we-perspective" and the "I-perspective. " His examine of robust collective intentionality -- as expressed via joint intentions, collective dedication, workforce trust, authority-based staff motion, and different phenomena -- outlines the situations less than which a person is needed to imagine and act as a bunch member.

Reinterpreting Property

This number of essays via one of many country's top estate theorists revitalizes the liberal character thought of estate. Departing from conventional libertarian and monetary theories of estate, Margaret Jane Radin argues that the legislations should still keep in mind nonmonetary own price hooked up to property—and that a few issues, corresponding to physically integrity, are so own they need to no longer be thought of estate in any respect.

Extra resources for Challenging Liberalism: Feminism as Political Critique

Show sample text content

And the communitarian imaginative and prescient of people, within which we're at middle and basically what our traditions have made us, is a imaginative and prescient that leaves decreased scope for feminist critique. (70–71) basically, she makes a big aspect the following: the communitarian view that people are outlined via their groups and via “traditions” is hardly ever a 98 Abstraction, beliefs, and Feminist Methodologies feminist view. besides the fact that, given the numerous and greatly said modifications among feminism and mainstream communitarianism, it really is uncertain why Nussbaum contains the communitarian critique of liberalism in her dialogue of the feminist critique of abstraction.

Three) that's, if we're to grasp even if anything counts as an injurious speech act, we have to be capable of pin down the social context and provides a static account of the conventions and rituals that govern that context. Butler means that this can be in precept very unlikely, given that conventions and rituals Speech, Authority, and Social Context a hundred forty five are constantly topic to change—even the heritage and present knowing of them is open to reinterpretation. Butler takes her feedback of the static account of social constitution and applies it to the theorists who view hate speech as illocutionary.

Via reading how gender and the constructions of sexism impact women’s lives, feminists have constructed theories that seriously research male dominance, and so they have devised techniques for not easy and altering those constructions. hence, feminist method consists of taking on the perspective of girls, examining numerous phenomena from the point of view of ladies residing inside of buildings of male dominance. From this angle, “equality” isn't really a question of summary “sameness” (nor is it a fight to develop into “just like men”), yet really is known to require remedying the unjust hierarchies of domination that constitution, confine, and form women’s lives.

285. 7. Ibid. , 306. eight. Ibid. , 293. nine. Mapel, Social Justice Reconsidered, 50–51. 10. For a longer dialogue of the superiority of “luck egalitarianism” within the paintings of latest political philosophy, see Anderson, “What Is the purpose of Equality? ” eleven. R. Dworkin, “What Is Equality? half 2: Equality of Resources,” 331; emphasis further. 12. Ibid. , 307. thirteen. R. Dworkin, “Liberal Community,” 481. 14. Susan Babbitt has argued that liberal theorists forget to contemplate the ways that contributors themselves will be remodeled if social buildings have been to alter noticeably.

Brown, States of damage, 40–41. eight. Ibid. , ninety seven, a hundred. nine. She pronounces that this can be her goal in penning this essay: “I are looking to replicate upon where of rights within the politics of politicized identities—rights of ‘inclusion’ in addition to rights of ‘difference’ at present looked for humans of colour, homosexuals, and ladies within the late-twentieth-century usa” (ibid. ). 10. “It would seem provisional resolution to the query of the price of rights language for girls is that it really is deeply paradoxical: rights safe our status as contributors whilst they imprecise the treacherous ways that that status is completed and controlled; they need to be particular and urban for you to display and redress women’s subordination, but in all likelihood entrench our subordination via that specificity” (Brown, “Suffering Rights as Paradoxes,” 238).

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.63 of 5 – based on 8 votes